Last edited 2 weeks ago
by Peter Riegler

Dependent variable vs name of function: Difference between revisions

(init)
 
(-typo)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Hint|text= '''How to use this template'''
# Start by describing the bottleneck in the Section '''Description of Bottleneck'''. If you like you can orient yourself on the bottleneck description [[From Derivative to Proportionality]]. If you feel able to turn the bottleneck into a (positive) learning outcome, please do also describe the intended learning outcome.
# This wiki also serves to connect people interested in certain bottlenecks. If you wish to make yourself known as interested, fill in your name under '''People interested in this Bottleneck'''.
# When done editing, save page.
# When in reading mode, add suitable tags/categories by pressing the tag symbol on the top of the page. For instance, if the bottleneck is in connection to biology, add "biology" as a tag.
# Edit once again and delete the whole Section '''How to use this Template''' and save your changes.
}}
==Description of bottleneck==
==Description of bottleneck==
In mathematics and in particual in the STEM disciplines one often does not symbolically distinguish the name of a function and its dependent variable.
In mathematics and in particual in the STEM disciplines one often does not symbolically distinguish the name of a function and its dependent variable.
Line 12: Line 4:
For example, the time dependence (independent variable, symbolized by <math>t</math>) of an electrical charge <math>q</math> (dependent variable, symbolized by <math>q</math>)  might be described by a certain function <math>f(t)</math>, ''i.e.'' <math>q = f(t)</math>. Here different symbols have been used for the dependent variable <math>q</math> and the functional relationship <math>f</math> (between <math>t</math> and <nowiki></q></nowiki>). It is, however, customary to conflate this and to use <math> q</math> to do denote both dependent variable and functional relationship. This results in the using the experession <math>q(t)</math>.
For example, the time dependence (independent variable, symbolized by <math>t</math>) of an electrical charge <math>q</math> (dependent variable, symbolized by <math>q</math>)  might be described by a certain function <math>f(t)</math>, ''i.e.'' <math>q = f(t)</math>. Here different symbols have been used for the dependent variable <math>q</math> and the functional relationship <math>f</math> (between <math>t</math> and <nowiki></q></nowiki>). It is, however, customary to conflate this and to use <math> q</math> to do denote both dependent variable and functional relationship. This results in the using the experession <math>q(t)</math>.


Interestingly this possible [[Bottleneck]] was revealed during an [[Decoding interview]] on students' difficulties with describing piecewise defined functions. The interviewers got confused by interviewees simultaneous usage of a symbol as the independent variable of a function and as the name of the functional relation.
Interestingly this possible [[Bottleneck]] was revealed during an [[Decoding interview]] on students' difficulties with describing piecewise defined functions. The interviewers got confused by interviewee's simultaneous usage of a symbol as the independent variable of a function and as the name of the functional relation.
==People interested in this bottleneck==
==People interested in this bottleneck==
Peter Riegler
Peter Riegler


[[Category:Bottleneck]]
[[Category:Bottleneck]]
[[Category:Mathematics]]

Latest revision as of 18:55, 21 November 2025

Description of bottleneck

In mathematics and in particual in the STEM disciplines one often does not symbolically distinguish the name of a function and its dependent variable.

For example, the time dependence (independent variable, symbolized by <math>t</math>) of an electrical charge <math>q</math> (dependent variable, symbolized by <math>q</math>) might be described by a certain function <math>f(t)</math>, i.e. <math>q = f(t)</math>. Here different symbols have been used for the dependent variable <math>q</math> and the functional relationship <math>f</math> (between <math>t</math> and </q>). It is, however, customary to conflate this and to use <math> q</math> to do denote both dependent variable and functional relationship. This results in the using the experession <math>q(t)</math>.

Interestingly this possible Bottleneck was revealed during an Decoding interview on students' difficulties with describing piecewise defined functions. The interviewers got confused by interviewee's simultaneous usage of a symbol as the independent variable of a function and as the name of the functional relation.

People interested in this bottleneck

Peter Riegler